Living a life of vow

A record of my training as a chaplain and other things Zen.

Saturday, February 2, 2013

Mercy - entering the chaos of another


Finally read a piece suggested by a chaplain colleague in which a priest offers his way to meet suffering.  No pat answers, only presence.  The final two paragraphs are an expression of why work as a chaplain in so dear.


"A contemporary theologian has described mercy as “entering into the chaos of another.” Christmas is really a celebration of the mercy of God who entered the chaos of our world in the person of Jesus, mercy incarnate. I have never found it easy to be with people who suffer, to enter into the chaos of others. Yet, every time I have done so, it has been a gift to me, better than the wrapped and ribboned packages. I am pulled out of myself to be love’s presence to someone else, even as they are love’s presence to me.
I will never satisfactorily answer the question “Why?” because no matter what response I give, it will always fall short. What I do know is that an unconditionally loving presence soothes broken hearts, binds up wounds, and renews us in life. This is a gift that we can all give, particularly to the suffering. When this gift is given, God’s love is present and Christmas happens daily."
Full article is here.
I then tracked down the theologian and got lost a bit in the christian focus of mercy as an act that leads to salvation.  This seems so different from the choicelessness of the work of the Bodhisattva.  The "gift" goes both ways.  I don't offer mercy so much as I am willing to be present so that suffering can be relieved.  
However it is born, may Christmas happen daily for us all.
(Thanks JR.)

Can't help but think of Michelle Shocked's song, The Quality of Mercy

Thursday, January 31, 2013

Talk about crazy hope


The assignment was to free associate.  What fun.

“The capacity for faith is at its strongest in childhood; which is why religions apply themselves before all else to getting those tender years into their possession....Religion is truth expressed in allegory and myth and thus made accessible and digestible to mankind at large...Religion is like a glow worm that is only visible in the darkness.”  (Arthur Schopenhauer, German Philosopher 1788-1860)


Are you kidding?  Really?  Someone wrote that down / said it out loud?  That the goal is to catch’em young when they are most impressionable?  That implies that the tenets of religion won’t stand the test of reasoned scrutiny (associated with adulthood and a more mature mind).  It makes explicit that religion is something that needs to be snuck in, under the radar.  Something that folks get hooked in to -  habituated to -  before they can question. (Wait, but wasn’t that something Schopenhaurer was trying to make plain?  Ah!)

This certainly is what I experienced in my brief Roman Catholic upbringing.  There was an explicit positioning of authority, of a source of wisdom that I was to accept without question.  Youthful questioner that I was, it didn’t work.  I kept asking questions that were not answered to my satisfaction.  And thus, the Roman Catholic becomes a Buddhist - a “practice” more than a religion, in which the core commandment is to sit, see for yourself.

Funny, as a result of practice, I have a greater respect for spiritual and religious authority – but I have an internal barometer that tells me when that authority is real. It’s something that is so evident, i.e., when someone is grounded as a result of personal exploration and inquiry.  And it is a very different presence from someone who is speaking more from faith than from inquiry and exploration.  I wish I could define it clearly – engagement is evident, openness is evident, active listening, compassion, and love. 

I’ve been in the presence of that authority: the words and lives of my Zen teachers, reading the works of contemporary Zen teachers like Okumura, Jetsunma Tenzin Palmo – a British zen teacher in the Tibetan tradition who lived for over a decade in a cave in the Himalayas, or Ostaseski, or the hospital's own Rev. S when she speaks about what is happening in a pastoral counseling encounter.  The words and ideas shared by these people ring true.  Religion does not give their words authority, their words and experience gives authority to their religion, as they illuminate universal, human truth from the ground of their faith.

And just this weekend, I heard its opposite.  A woman who was deeply grounded in her faith. Who attends regular Bible study.  Who spoke about her concern for her husband’s lack of faith.  And the most poignant statement from that encounter was this:  “I know better, and yet, as I think about it…the lust for life is so strong…..I am so surprised, so ashamed.”  She was unable to find what she sought from her religion – a world view, reassurance, an end to fear, and comfort.

So what does Buddhism offer to me?  Every morning (okay, most mornings), I rise from sleep and sit with myself on a cushion in a cold room.  I watch what I have come to think of as the uncontrollable “drool” of my mind activate.  I practice saying “okay” and “what next”.  I practice a lightness of view.  When the fears emerge I see them as part of that uncontrollable, unstoppable-as-long-as-I-am-living drool of thought, and have “faith” that something else will follow, a new fear, a new question, a new joy, a new anger, a new insight, a new inanity.  I practice compassion towards all of it and treat it….as I would drool.  I take it, and myself, with appropriate lightness.  Then, despite whatever has emerged, I say these words: “May this practice end greed, anger, delusion, and the hardship of all beings.” 

It undercuts ego.  I can’t end all suffering, but I have a “faith” that the practice of clear seeing and presence, done by millions over millennia, might have the energy to free us all. 

Talk about crazy hope. 

“A glowworm invisible only in the dark”?  Hmmm.  In a sutra recited daily, Buddhists say: 

“Light is also darkness, do not move with it as darkness.  Darkness is light, do not see it as light.  Light and darkness are not one, not two.  Like the foot before and the foot behind in walking, each thing has its own being, which is not different from its place and function.”  Light illuminates differences.  Darkness shows them to be less meaningful.  In the dim glow, perhaps we can just be wary and not bump our heads in heedless disrespect of the terrain of our faith and our very-human struggle!

Monday, December 31, 2012

Begin again

2nd CPE unit commences in January.  I confess to missing this work - this despite being up to my eyeballs in finding my way in a new job.  But the lesson of that new job, of the year's challenges to my health, family, and sanity - is that everything is chaplaincy.  That is, everything comes down to the single instances of presence and connection.  Connection with others.  Connection with that which lies quiet beneath the "self".   Each moment is complete in itself.  Though looking back on the year, I see the habit of trying to see them as a continuous whole - stringing each together - as bright as dew drops on the thin strands of Indra's net - and a construct as impermanent.  And I note - the drops are many.  It was a good year.


Wrapping up notes from 2012

Here are some notes on a memorable set of recent articles and books on EOL issues - scattered across papers and apps and devices and oy - what a 1st world 21st century problem

  • Joe Klein's TIME ">video on his piece in the NYT in June - The Long Goodbye.  I liked his statement about candor.  The video link appeared at the bottom of a TIME magazine piece with Five Tips on EOL care that seemed a helpful summary of what I've been reading of late.  What's not explicitly stated is the advice to ask for a consultation with the palliative care team.  Oh, but wait, it seems such teams re not in every hospital.  That was an eye opener to me when I interviewed at a local hospital.  Yikes!
  • My LibraryThing notes in Never Say Die by Susan Jacoby:  Really good read.  Reflects fully my experience as a chaplain where patients struggle to reconcile their experience with the frankly offensive "boosterism" of the culture.  Busy blaming themselves for aging, or feeling guilty because they can't see the bright side of suffering, all distract from an ability to approach what are dwindling opportunities for integration and peace.  I think I'll own that anger as Jacoby suggests and see if I can do something with it!
  • Excellent Hasting Center post on language at end-of-life.  I especially liked calling out the consumer-ification:  "The second is that the reframe prompts a shift away from a rhetoric of “choices” to one of making decisions, some of them hard. It may seem counterintuitive, but the current trope – patients and families are making choices – promotes the illusion that there is some “right” choice out there and that if they only knew or studied enough, they would make it. It’s a consumerist logic, and it translates easily into thinking that the patient’s situation can be fixed by having plenty of the “right stuff’’ – more tests and procedures."    Read more:http://www.thehastingscenter.org/Bioethicsforum/Post.aspx?id=5109&blogid=140#ixzz2GfAn6leJ
  • NYT on older couples facing dementia  http://nyti.ms/IEexYs
  • Quotes from The End of Faith:  "The rules of civil discourse demand that reason wear a veil whenever she goes out in public.".... "Theology is now little more that a branch of ignorance, ignorance with wings."..."What can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence. - Christopher Hitchins"
  • Pain is inevitable, but suffering is optional. - Thich Nhat Hanh, The Nobility of Suffering
  • Came across a quote from someone very wise at SJR:  "When you deal with grief all the others (griefs) that are unresolved come forward for attention as well."  This has proven true over and over again.
  • Poured through some notes I took on becoming a board certified chaplain.  In truth, it seems ever more unlikely.  But I will do the work as a volunteer nonetheless.  I appreciate the training and despair of the hoops and hurdles.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

Notes on couples from April


Last week I met three different couples whose stories were fundamentally the same - long marriage, geographically distant children, one partner losing to dementia or Alzheimers, the other struggling to imagine what to do next.  The encounters were heartbreaking and inspiring at the same time.  


My favorite was the outrageously sweet Italiam man married to a “Scotch Irish and you know what their temper is like” woman with Alzheimers.  Both in their 80s, he’d been caring for her for over three years.  Now it has become too hard.  After this stay in the hospital she would go to a nursing home; but he would be there every day.  With each scattered phrase she uttered, his attention, devotion, and care were evident.  He would have said, as another woman said of her husband of 61 years (the last 5 years with Alzheimers) - "He’s my bashert."


I spoke with the wife of the third couple.  She shared a bit of who they were and where they found themselves now.  She spoke softly when she talked of the unexpected anger that had emerged in her husband’s illness.  She then turned to me and asked: Isn’t it just depressingly sad to hear these stories?  


Yes, I answered, the stories are sad, but they also give me hope.  I can see more clearly that we are all in the same boat - and I wonder how I can get us all to pull together so we can feel less alone.

Never Say Die: The myth and marketing of the new old age by Susan Jacoby c2011

Juicy bits:

"I do not believe in an immortal soul independent of the human body, because I do not believe in God or any form of supernaturalism.  Nor do I argue, as some psychologists and philosophers do, that there is a mind or consciousness independent of the intractable materials mass of gray matter that is the human brain.  To contend that consciousness (like spirituality) is a phenomenon separate from or greater than the brain itself strikes me as just another refusal to acknowledge that homo sapiens, with the most sophisticated brain of all species on earth, nevertheless belongs to the animal kingdom.  What others call the mind or the spirit is the literally marvelous result of what the brain, a physical organ, has made of its encounters with stimuli over a lifetime."

Notes undertreatment of pain in Alzheimer patients because they can't express their circumstances clearly.

"One of the most frequent promises that husbands an wives makes to each other is that neither will put the other in a nursing home."  So you'd think we'd judge the avail drugs by their ability to keep people out of institutions.  They do nothing - merely palliative.  Give us the sense we're doing something. The drugs given are palliative."

Old age is a woman's issue.  Decries the puffery about the wisdom of old to identify a purpose for the longer lives lived today.

"I do not know whether any death can truly be called good, decent, or dignified.  For me the physical reality of the end, the flickering out, whether slow or fast, of brain neurons that have communicated with one another so brilliantly to form the life experience of one member of our species - one beloved member - overwhelms everything else.  To an atheist, death -whether it comes as a thief in the night or through sudden. violent confrontation - is no more and no less than he fate all humans share.  Take away supernatural hopes and one is left with nature, which is neither decent not indecent.  The difference between "do everything" and "do everything - but stop when there is no more to be done" lies not in any spurious distinction between the "unnatural" (ventilators and tubes) and the "natural" (palliative care at home or in a hospice) but in the recognition that human intelligence itself is a part of and not the master of nature. Acceptance of the point at which intelligence and its inventions can no longer battle the ultimate natural master, death, is a true affirmation of what it means to be human."

"The issue is not whether it is morally wrong to want to live longer but whether it makes sense for a society to assume the costs that will inevitably be associated with a longer period of old age for more of its members.  ....as long as Americans continue to believe in the myth that each of us possesses the power to create our own economy, we will be paralyzed, as a society, in our effort to meet the huge challenges to our institutions posed by the impending old age, and old old age, of the boomers."

"The central emotional challenge of advanced old age, as distinct from financial issues, is the establishment of a livable balance between autonomy and dependence."

"Laying claim to the right to feel rotten about what is happening can free up energy for the fight to live as well as possible through whatever life hands us as we grow older."

"The case against the propagation of [the myth and marketing of young old age] is much clearer when considering large social issues in an aging society, because faith in the future victory of science over old age and its discontents is bound to divert energy and money from the urgent task of devising new institutions and strategies to meet the needs of the old as they are now.  But it is more difficult to make the case, on an individual basis, against the [xxx] of hope for a new old age....Even if there is little fact based justification [can it be no more deleterious to adults than he myth of Santa Claus to children?]  ...adults are not children, even though they are often treated as children.  Hope is not incompatible with realism, but it is incompatible with the expectation that things are going to turn out well if we only conduct ourselves well.  Inflated expectations about successful aging, if the body imposes a cruel old age, can lead to real despair....

"The myth of the young old age spreads a miasma that obscures the intensity of memory and vision - not wisdom - that is the gift of sentience if one is fortunate enough to remain aware until the end."

Poem by Ch’ang-hui



on a peak standing still

only clouds coming and going

a thousand misty mountains below me

in the open sitting straight

nothing false  nothing real

shapes of light and dark before me